RenderBid
‹ All articlesRunning the business

The 50/30/15 test: is your home improvement company keeping enough of every dollar?

By Dave Roland, Co-Founder and COO

A home improvement company owner reviewing his numbers at his desk, with siding, window, and deck samples behind him

Ask a home improvement owner how the year went and you'll usually hear a revenue number. Revenue matters, but it doesn't tell you whether the business is healthy. Plenty of companies sell more every year and keep less of it.

Here's a quick test you can run on your own P&L in about ten minutes. We call it the 50/30/15 test.

What 50/30/15 means

Picture every dollar that comes in the door, and split it three ways:

  • About 50 cents builds the job. Materials and installation labor: siding, boards, windows, and the crew that puts them in. Your accountant calls this cost of goods sold, or job cost.
  • About 30 cents sells the job and runs the company. Leads and marketing, sales commission, the office, trucks, insurance, software, and everyone who isn't on a crew.
  • About 15 cents is profit. What the business keeps after everything is paid.

The last nickel or so covers what doesn't fit neatly anywhere else: warranty work, callbacks, and a cushion for the slow months.

Where it comes from

The idea started in personal finance. In their 2005 book All Your Worth, Elizabeth Warren and Amelia Warren Tyagi suggested spending 50% of take-home pay on needs, 30% on wants, and saving 20%. Accountants later borrowed the same shape for small businesses: half to direct costs, about a third to overhead, and the rest as profit.

The exact numbers shift by industry, and that's fine. It isn't a law; it's a smoke detector. When one of the three buckets is far off, something in the business needs attention.

How to run the test on your company

  1. 1.Pull last year's P&L, or the last twelve months.
  2. 2.Add up job cost: materials, installation labor, subcontractors, permits, and dumpsters.
  3. 3.Add up sell and run: marketing and leads, sales commission, office salaries, rent, vehicles, insurance, and software.
  4. 4.Profit is what's left.
  5. 5.Divide each one by revenue.

What your split is telling you

Job cost well over 55%. Usually a pricing problem, not a production problem. The most common cause is discounting: every 10% a rep takes off the price comes straight out of the same materials and labor. A tight price presentation protects this bucket better than haggling with suppliers. (More on that in why reps lead with the discount.)

Sell and run well over 35%. Usually a close rate problem, not a marketing problem. Your leads aren't too expensive; too many of them are leaving without a signature.

Profit under 10%. You're working hard for the business instead of the other way around. Many remodelers net around 10%, so 15% is a real goal, but it's very reachable for a company with a strong in-home sale.

The lever most owners miss

Here's the part that changes how you think about the 30.

Most of the "sell and run" bucket doesn't grow when you close more. Your lead spend is the same whether a rep closes 30% or 33% of appointments. So is the office, the rent, and the trucks. Commission grows, but only as a share of the new revenue.

That means a better close rate does two things at once: it adds revenue, and it shrinks the 30 as a share of every dollar. Here's a company running 500 appointments a year at a $45,000 average job:

Closing 30%Closing 33%
Jobs a year150165
Revenue$6,750,000$7,425,000
Job cost (50%)$3,375,000$3,712,500
Commission (10%)$675,000$742,500
Leads and marketing$675,000$675,000
Office and overhead$675,000$675,000
Warranty and cushion (5%)$337,500$371,250
Profit$1,012,500 (15%)$1,248,750 (16.8%)

Same leads, same office, same trucks. Three more points of close rate added $236,250 of profit, and "sell and run" dropped from 30% of revenue to about 28%.

Three ways to move your split without buying more leads

1. Fix one-party appointments. When only one homeowner is at the table, the deal rarely closes that night, and you've spent the lead either way. Set every appointment with both decision makers. (See what one-party appointments really cost.)

2. Present the price in the right order. Retail value first, then your promotion, then the ways to pay. Reps who follow the order stop giving away margin that the homeowner never asked for, and that protects your 50.

3. Keep the jobs you sign. Every cancellation is a lead you paid for, a commission conversation, and an evening your rep spent, with nothing to show for it. Homeowners who saw the project on their own house and chose their own option are far less likely to back out. (See signed Friday, canceled Monday.)

Run the test, then see what closing more is worth

Run the 50/30/15 test on last year's P&L. If your 30 is heavy or your 15 is light, the fastest fix usually isn't cutting costs or buying more leads. It's closing more of the appointments you're already running.

Want to see what a few points of close rate would do for your company? Try the free ROI calculator, or book a demo and we'll walk through it with you.

Your next step

See how your split changes when you close more

On a 30-minute demo we go through your appointments, close rate, and average job, and show what closing more of the leads you already pay for does to your bottom line.